Victorian State Coroner Liberty Sanger announced on Friday, November 20, 2026, that she is reopening the coronial investigation into the 2019 death of Victoria Police Sergeant Shona O’Connor.

Reopening Detail

  • The decision relies on amendments to the Coroners Act that took effect on November 1, 2026, allowing the Coroners Court of Victoria to reopen an investigation on its own motion when new facts emerge, without a formal application from the family.
  • The reopening follows the November 9, 2026, ABC Four Corners episode “Unprofessional,” which revealed that key evidence regarding alleged bullying and sexual harassment at the Melton police station was left out of the original coronial brief.
  • State Coroner Sanger specifically noted in her determination that the original brief lacked a statement from Local Area Commander Inspector Zorka Dunstan, who stated that Sergeant O’Connor had reported bullying allegations roughly a month before her death.
  • Victoria Police Chief Commissioner Mike Bush acknowledged the omitted statements should have been provided to the court and indicated he would support a public hearing if the coroner orders one.

What the Chief Commissioner didn’t say, and what is critical, is the opening of an investigation by Victoria Police into the identity of those who were part of the conspiracy to withhold evidence from the Coroner.

There is little doubt that the Chief should have opened an investigation as soon as he became aware that the evidence was withheld. If the Chief has, he must promptly indicate this.

There is no doubt the Coroner will want to know who withheld the evidence and why.

This withholding of evidence could lead to criminal charges of Perverting the Course of Justice, Conspiracy to Pervert the Course of Justice and Misconduct in Public Office, three serious indictable charges that could see perpetrators face jail time.

We are very disappointed in this inaction, as we held Chief Commissioner Bush in a higher regard, unlikely to perpetuate a criminal cover-up.

This Bullying, and cover-up issue could not have come at a worse time for the Chief, when in a week’s time, according to the opinion polls, the Government will change, and he may lose the support of the Government that appointed him, and there is no guarantee the new Government will support him; his actions in this matter may prove decisive to his future.

What cannot be discounted is the likelihood of a Class Action against VicPol and the State, and the cost and image damage will not sit well with any government, particularly as all the issues of multiple victims will be aired and perpetrators named.

The importance of the Sergeant Shona O’Connor story cannot be overstated as a watershed moment in Victoria Police history, with the likelihood of serious ramifications rattling through the corridors of power within the Force that will take a very long time to recover from.

What is becoming evident is the depth and reach of this insidious behaviour, and there is, without question, a direct impact on the community, with a Force that cannot police itself and therefore fails to adequately police and protect the community. Simply throwing more police numbers at the problem is not the solution but is more likely to perpetuate it.

How broad is this insidious practice, and what other areas of policing does this cover-up practice permeate? What other Court matters, inquiries or commissions have had evidence withheld to protect the guilty?

The CAA has been advised, and has compelling evidence, that, at the very least, the practice is alive and well in the management of Firearms Registry matters and widespread in the mishandling of property in police custody.

Not surprisingly, the number of former members of VicPol whose careers were destroyed by the bullying and cover-ups Shona experienced, and who are now prepared to speak out, has provided some valuable takeaways.

The number one issue is that the Force ethos of protecting the perpetrators at the expense of the victims must be reversed.

The perpetrators are allowed to continue their careers unimpeded, with promotion and retirement without sanction for their behaviour, often criminal, to enjoy their superannuation, while the victims are left sometimes destitute as broken people suffering for the rest of their lives, many with shattered partners and relationships.

Again, overwhelmingly, the victims of this horrendous and unlawful treatment express a common thread as to why they are prepared to tell their story.

They want to protect others from experiencing their fate.
Although there is a gender bias, with female members in the majority by a small margin, the bullying transcends not only gender but ranks.

We are currently in discussions with a former Commissioner, a Superintendent, and an Inspector, so bullying is not confined to other ranks but extends to all levels within the Force, indicating the depth of the problem.

As identified by one victim, the recruiting drive VicPol is currently undertaking can arguably be an exercise in increasing the number of victims and only having a marginal impact on improving community policing.

Before getting extra grist for the bullying mill, the Force needs to fix the problem first.

There are calls for the need for external intervention to solve the issue, but the solution already exists and is ignored.

External intervention will have minimal impact, cost millions, and take years, whereas the Force applying the law will create a deterrent that doesn’t currently exist and have an immediate impact.

Most of the cases we are seeing clearly indicate criminal acts by the bullies, and they need to be properly investigated by competent and impartial Police determined to stamp the practice out.

Whether it is management or the mindset of investigators within the internal Professional Standards regime, they cannot claim they are unaware of this issue, but there is no evidence they are acting to stamp it out, given the depth and breadth of the issue; therefore, they are complicit in allowing the Ethical Standards of the Force to diminish.

Crime prevention is as critical within the Force as the Community and must be given a higher priority.

Whether the perpetrators are still serving or retired makes no difference, as the need for a proper investigation remains, and if evidence indicates a criminal offence that will stand up to scrutiny beyond reasonable doubt, the perpetrator must be charged and brought before the Court, no ifs, no buts.

Leaving the issue of guilt or innocence where it should lie, with the Courts.

This will provide some closure and vindication for the many victims who continue to suffer every day.

Watch the circumstances within the Force change dramatically when bullies and those prepared to cover things up realise retirement is not an escape route from responsibility for their actions or inaction, and their Superannuation, nest egg, is severely damaged by legal fees defending their charges.

Being arrested, charged, and brought before a Court will set the precedent that bullying and cover-ups will not be tolerated.

The situation has deteriorated so much; simple words from the Chief Commissioner will not be enough without decisive action; hollow promises won’t wash.

As we set up our Task group, the number and quality of retired Police volunteers prepared to assist us is very encouraging, speaking volumes about the character of the broader Force.

Our team has a lot of work to do reviewing the submissions received so far, so time will be an issue that additional volunteers may alleviate.

If you believe you have been or are a victim, or want to help, please let us know at CEO@caainc.org.au